Best Italian Restaurant in Indiana

Indiana's Italian Haven for Flavor, Tradition, and Family Connection

Featured

Welcome to Sal's Famous Pizzeria In

Experience the true taste of Italy at our family-run restaurant in Plainfield and Brownsburg. We take pride in our heritage, using recipes passed down through generations. Sal makes fresh dough every day and mixes custom sauces from the finest imported tomatoes. Whether you visit us on Main Street in either town, you will find a cozy atmosphere and friendly service. Come share a table with us today.

View Our Story

Fresh Pasta and Hearth-Baked Pizzas

We serve amazing wood-fired pizzas baked over an Italian-style hearth to seal in every flavor. Our kitchen prepared fresh pasta, calzones, and lean meat dishes like chicken and veal daily. Finish your meal with a classic treat like our creamy tiramisu or crisp cannoli. Every dish is made using the freshest ingredients and natural products to ensure the highest standards for our local community and guests.

View Full Menu

Hot Italian Meals Ready for Pickup

Skip the line by ordering your favorites directly from our website. We offer quick takeout and delivery options so you can enjoy our handmade pizzas and salads anywhere. Our team ensures every online order is prepared with the same care as our dine-in service. It is the fastest way to bring a touch of Italy to your home tonight.

Order Online Now

A Glimpse of Our Kitchen

See our fresh dough, vibrant salads, and golden hearth-baked pizzas. We use the finest ingredients to create beautiful, authentic Italian meals every single day.

Sip & Savor

Professional Catering for Your Next Event

Let us bring the flavors of Sicily to your special gathering or office meeting. We provide large portions of our famous pasta, fresh salads, and specialty pizzas that guests will love. Our staff handles the details so you can focus on your event. We use the same high-quality meats and cheeses for our catering menu to ensure your guests enjoy a premium dining experience.

Book Catering

Two Convenient Spots for Family Dining

📍Plainfield: 350 E Main St, Plainfield, IN 46168 📍Brownsburg: 1028 E Main St, Brownsburg, IN 46112 Style: Full-service dining with a cozy, casual feel. Freshness: Dough and sauces made from scratch daily. Authenticity: Italian-style hearth baking for every pizza.

Find a Location

What our guests are saying

Always loved Sal's, a special place to our family used for special celebrations. Now love it even more since the new remodelling is so beautiful. Music makes experience so special. Our waitress Gabby was so sweet and very good at her job. She made our celebration even nicer. Thanks to all.

Debra R.

In the 20 years I’ve lived in Indiana, I have not been able to find decent Sicilian food. Thank you so much for the amazing meal. It was so good I literally had to give Sal a hug. Everything was high quality, and sauces were made fresh. Words don’t do it justice. Do yourself a favour and go eat at Sal's to see for yourself!

Lacie B.

We went to Sal’s for dinner. We had our 4 year girl and 1 year boy with us. The server, Jeremiah, was polite, interactive and attentive. He interacted with our children too. Food, as always, was delicious! Our kids actually eat it and don’t complain! Overall, we had a great experience as usual! We will be back!